Skip to main content

The Story of the 'Mexico' Disaster

In terms of loss of life, the Mexico Disaster, as it has become known, is still the most significant lifeboat disaster in the United Kingdom. The events of the night of 9 December 1886 in the Ribble estuary have been well documented, particularly in books and pamphlets by Frank Kilroy, Gilbert and John Mayes,  David Forshaw and J Allen Miller /Andrew Farthing. Anyone wanting full accounts of the events should consult these works (see 'Sources' below) but here are the essential details.

A few days before the Mexico disaster the lifeboats Laura Janet and Charles Biggs (from Lytham) had gone out to rescue the crew of a coast steamer, the Yan Yean, which had attempted to anchor in the Ribble estuary in adverse weather conditions but ended up on a sandbank and taking in water. The crew took to the rigging, only being rescued at the last moment. This was the first successful rescue by the St Anne's lifeboat station.

The storm that had wrecked the Yan Yean worsened and on Wednesday 8 December became full storm force. In the wake of this the German barque Mexico, after trying to anchor in the estuary, was grounded close to Southport and sent up a distress flare at 9pm on Thursday 9 December. Lifeboats from Lytham, St Anne’s and Southport were launched to attempt a rescue. The men of the Lytham boat successfully saved the crew of the Mexico but the captain of the German vessel said that he had not seen any other lifeboats and Charles Biggs's crew were unaware of the fate of the boats from Southport and St Anne’s.

There were two survivors from the Southport vessel who managed to get out of the boat when it hit sand and made for the shore. One of these two, Henry Robinson, had been assisted by a man called Rimmer who reported the incident to the Birkdale police and news of the disaster spread. The Eliza Fernley had actually got within twenty yards of the Mexico when she was turned over by a large wave and would not right herself. Most of the crew were trapped underneath and succumbed to the cold and lack of oxygen. Searches along the shoreline soon began to find bodies. Some had already passed away whilst others lasted a short while before dying. There was one other survivor, John Jackson, who had been washed ashore and managed to walk back home.

Meanwhile there was no news of the Laura Janet. A telegram from Southport reported that three unidentified bodies had been found and William Yates, Landsman at the St Anne's station went by train to Southport to identify them. He later telegraphed back to St Anne's that the upturned boat had been found and nine bodies of the missing crew had been recovered. All the remaining bodies were discovered soon after apart from that of a Thomas Bonney which was washed up in Southport in the following March.

The bodies of twenty-two men were laid out in the stables at the Palace Hotel in Birkdale, Southport which had become a makeshift mortuary. Many people in the town came to view the bodies and there are several accounts in newspaper reports. There were also some harrowing descriptions of the scenes in sermons given at local churches and subsequently reported by the press. The bodies of the St Anne's men came home by train and were returned to the families in Lytham and St Anne’s prior to the funerals which took place on Tuesday 14 December.



Postcard commemorating the crew of the Eliza Fernley

The story is a truly tragic one and it was one which at the time precipitated concerted efforts to raise funds for the families of the deceased in both St Anne's and Southport.  A central disaster fund was established and subsequently local committees in both towns administered the funds and made provision for the families over a number of years. The minutes of the St Anne’s Disaster Committee give a fascinating insight into Victorian philanthropy which is becoming part of my wider research.

Once such provisions were established surplus funds were then made available for monuments in the local areas. Southport has a memorial in Duke Street Cemetery and there is also an obelisk on the promenade which commemorates the loss of life in the Mexico disaster as well as the work of local lifeboat crews generally. In the Lytham St Annes area, along with the promenade monument, there are memorials in graveyards at St Cuthbert's Church, Lytham and St Anne’s Church, St Anne's as well as Layton Cemetery, Blackpool. My focus is the promenade monument at St Anne's and future posts will look more closely at its design, commissioning and unveiling.

Sources

Forshaw, David. On Those Infernal Ribble Banks: A Record of Lifesaving By the Lifeboats of Lytham St Annes. 2nd ed edition. Great Northern Pub, 2006.

Kilroy, Frank. The Wreck of the 'Mexico'. Rev. ed.]. Lytham: R.N.L.I., Lytham St. Annes Branch, 2012.

 Mayes, Gilbert I., and J. E. Mayes. On a Broad Reach: The History of the St Anne’s-on-the-Sea Lifeboat Station 1881-1925. Bernard McCall, 2000.

 The Mexico Disaster 9th December 1886. Lytham St Annes: Lytham Heritage Group, 2011.

Miller, J. Allen. The Great Lifeboat Disaster of 1886. Edited by Andrew N. Farthing. Southport: Sefton Council, Leisure Services Department, 2001.



 Andrew Walmsley, July 2020

https://www.lancaster.ac.uk/history/about/people/andrew-walmsley

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Working Class Heroes?

'Life Boat Monument, St Anne's on Sea', Wyndham Series Postcard, 1902 One thing that continues to fascinate me about William Birnie Rhind's Mexico Monument is the depiction of an ordinary man as the focal point of a piece of civic sculpture. In present times, with a now established interest in local history and 'history from below', we are much more used to seeing working-class heritage and the lives of ordinary people celebrated in sculpture.* For example, we have a recently unveiled monument to Wigan miner s or, closer to home,  The Shrimper  in Lowther Gardens in Lytham. Miners' Monument (2021), Steve Winterburn, Wigan However, when the  Mexico  Monument was unveiled in May 1886 it would have been highly unusual to see an ordinary man, or for that matter, even an ordinary seaman or soldier, as the focal point of a piece of statuary in Great Britain. One of the few examples might be considered to be Rhind's memorial to the Black Watch, unveiled in 18...

The 'Mexico' Disaster and the Poetry of Commemoration

The Mexico monument at St Anne’s was, and is, a focal point for collective mourning and a means of continuous celebration of the heroism of the lifeboatmen lost in the disaster of 1886. Although the monument formalized these processes they really began very soon after the disaster happened as emotive depictions of  the event and its aftermath appeared across various print media. It is a common conception that as a nation (and I speak here perhaps more of England than Britain collectively) we have latterly become far more likely to express emotion both as individuals and collectively. Critics of this perceived trend suggest that we have become emotionally incontinent, less inclined to traditional English stoicism and reserve. However, a quick study of newspapers relating to national events over the preceding 150 years shows that the desire to express emotion collectively over a national event has been with us for a long time The mourning and commemoration surrounding the Mexico ...